Wednesday, April 16, 2008

There Must Be Some Way Out Of Here

cat burglar
About 2 or 3 times a year, someone cries foul about the New Music Reblog. Today, Gert from Mad Musings of Me called us 'nefarious thieves' and 'unscrupulous culprits'.

Before that, it was Charles Downey from Ionarts, who much more politely protested, "when you take the whole post -- images and text -- you are stealing my work and preventing people from coming to my site."

John Clare from Composing Thoughts also suggested the site was actually unlawful when he asked us to remove his blog from syndication.

All the New Music Reblog does is syndicate feeds from blogs about new music. What you see is what we get via RSS subscriptions.

Some people, like AC Douglas, and the NY Times' Artsbeat publish partial feeds, which give a one or two line teaser and link to the full post. Other folks, like Omniscient Mussel and Alex Ross publish their whole post in their feeds.

The Reblog mechanism receives all that information, and we look at it and republish posts that relate to the relatively loose concept of 'new music'.

If your entire blog is being published on the site, it is because you are sending that content to us in your feed. The solution is simplistic in the extreme. If you don't want your entire posts published, provide a partial feed, and of course, if that's not an option, we're happy to remove your feed from syndication.

Certainly no harm is meant with this simple little reblog site. Jeff created a wonderful clearinghouse for the myriad of voices who are paying attention to this small little sector of the arts. Our goal is not to steal any content from anyone, but rather to make it easier to find.

Labels: , ,

2 Comments:

Blogger David Toub said...

Hey jodru, I'm perfectly fine with your keeping my blog on the NM Reblog (you did update your feed link to my new blog site, yes?). Sure, it might decrease site visits, but as you state, anyone can truncate his or her blog feed so that one has to go to the site to view the entire post. Personally, I stopped doing that some time ago because as a user, I found it annoying when I have to go to the site itself to read an entire feed.

10:05 PM  
Blogger Daniel Wolf said...

New Music ReBlog is a great service. Among other things, it allows my feed to be read in countries like China or Iran or in schools in Germany which censor all blogspot sites.

4:27 PM  

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home